We thank our wonderful customers for continuing to support small businesses like ours!! For new customers considering us, we try to offer exemplary customer service and competitive prices on our webstore and in our Mt Airy store, if you are able to visit with us personally.

Beginning 7.18.22, our regular Fedex drop location is closed for a few days. You may experience an additional delay in shipping as we use an alternative location that doesn’t have daily collections. Contact us by email if you need additional information. Thank you for your patience.

With diesel prices rising as they are, be aware that freight for your shipments may be higher than what you previously expected. We apologize for what is beyond our control.

Consider USPS for lighter shipments. 

Product availability is sporadic on some items. We will do our utmost to fill your order complete. If items are not available, you will receive either a partial or full refund to your card.

Expect possible delays.

Welcome to Mill Creek General Store – Voted “Best Deli” & “Best Natural Foods” in 2018, “Best Sandwiches” in 2016, and “Best Health Food Store” & “Best Snack Food Store” in 2015 & 2014!!

We are a family-owned business that specializes in healthy, whole food options including Amish meats and cheeses,  gluten-free flours and foods, non-GMO foods, locally grown and produced goods, whole grains, freshly baked breads, specialty baking and candy supplies, all in bulk packaging at reasonable prices. Check out our Mill Creek Pointy Store listing for a full representation of the variety of products we offer. We also offer, hand-crafted, high-quality, Amish made furniture available in custom sizes, and we can ship anywhere!

Now Offering Gift/Wedding Registry!

A Store With A Choice

Mill Creek General Store is a solution to a void in Mt. Airy’s shopping options. We provide a variety of quality goods, giving the customer flexibility and choice that the “clubs” can’t provide. The customer can expect bulk pricing (sometimes greater than 50% savings) without the requirement of purchasing a huge quantity of the same product. And we can customize packaging if YOU need it.

While you wait, you may also shop our wide selection which includes a ginormous selection of chocolates and nuts, a large selection of organic products, a large health and beauty section, many sugar-free items, whole food and gluten-free selections, non-GMO foods, locally grown and produced goods, whole grains, freshly baked items, specialty baking and candy supplies, many offered in bulk packaging at reasonable prices.  Mill Creek also offers unique gift ideas and products for your home: RADA cutlery, handmade rugs and table accents, home interior décor, novelty items, Amish handcrafted leather items, Farm-to-Feet socks, as well as hand-crafted, high-quality, American made Amish furniture which can be ordered in custom sizes. We can ship anywhere! Now Offering Gift/Wedding Registry!

“Best Deli” & “Best Natural Foods” in 2018, “Best Sandwiches” in 2016, and “Best Health Food Store” & “Best Snack Food Store” in 2015 & 2014!!

"Make Me A Sammich!"

Our deli has become quite the rave of Mt. Airy! Our deli serves sandwiches, wraps, and salads prepared with Amish meats and cheeses and fresh local produce, the highest quality ingredients. Our Italian sandwich, the Shorty’s Mill, along with the Chicken Salad Croissant, the Mitchell’s Mill Club, and the Dellinger Mill Rueben are locally famous! All of our sandwiches are made-to-order, fresh! Enjoy your sandwich in our “free-to-dine-in” bistro area or take it to go! And don’t forget…our bistro furniture is for sale, too! We also offer delicious deli sandwich platters.

Remember, quality does require time for preparation. To order ahead, just call 336-755-2340 and ask for the deli. See our FB page, or we’re happy to email you a deli menu if you don’t have one.

Contact & Store Hours

Business Hours:
Sunday Closed
Monday – Saturday
9:30 A.M. – 6:00 P.M.

541 West Pine Street Suite 200
Mount Airy, North Carolina 27030

Phone:  336-755-2340

Holiday Hours:
Thanksgiving Eve – Close 6 pm
Thanksgiving Day – Closed, reopen day after 10:00 am
Christmas Eve – Close 2 pm
Christmas Day – Closed, reopen Dec 26th 11 am

New Year’s Eve – Close 5 pm, New Year’s Day – Closed. Reopen Jan 2, regular hours
Independence Day – Closed

Some Of Our Brands

Store Categories

You can now conveniently shop for our store goods in the comfort of your home or anywhere! Our online store is divided by the following categories: